Pondering Switching the Other Way
While I have been a Mac user for the past five years almost exclusively, I have been thinking lately about switching back to using a PC. The reasons for this truly stem from my need for the ultimate in geekery. I'd really like to get a dual-core Pentium 4. The tremendous advantage is that these cores also employ hyperthreading which to the OS looks like four discreet CPUs. Also, I have the urge to work in several 3D programs, none the least of which is Swift3D, that I have noticed run significantly faster on the newest Intel and AMD based machines than on the Macs.
But the Macs are going to go Intel you say. That is true, but the Mac prices aren't going to change. That is almost guaranteed. There is no way Apple is giving up it's hardware margins, nor should they. I have a choice, and I can get more bang for my buck going with a PC. This has always been true, but at one time I was happy with an iMac G3. The iMac has always been competetively priced relative to it's PC counterparts so I was content. When I first bought my G5 I was relatively content. Now the issue is that G5s cost about $2,000 at the entry level. I can take that money to Dell and get a Dual-Core P4 that will take it's lunch money on any given day, albeit with several crashes along the way.
But you by a Mac for the software, that is why it is worth it. This is true, and Mac OS X is definately superior to Windows XP and probably it's upcoming service pack, Windows Vista. I will miss it, but running Mac OS X does not enhance my productivity in any tangible way, it just looks better and the entire OS crashes less. I have had plenty of application crashes, which are about the same.
What it comes down to is what my current computing needs are vs my wallet, and in that game the Mac is at a severe disadvantage. We won't even talk about gaming. But the ultimate reason is my geekiness. I have a weak spot for Visual Studio 2005. After using several betas of the application via Microsoft's Express Beta program, I have to say I am impressed with the ease of developing using C# in this IDE. Their visual web developer software is equally compelling although unless I had to I wouldn't use ASP.net for just about anything. Not because it is bad, but because it takes so much longer to develop anything in than ColdFusion or PHP. Ultimately, my love of new technology and my desire to retain as much of my cash as possible is fueling this internal debate. I will probably not buy another Mac because of the cost, but at the same time I will not give up my iBook. I'll probably carry a Mac laptop for the forseeable future. My workhorse, the desktop however is definately another story.